At the South Cambs Planning Committee this morning the Mitre planning application for the development of the Bishop’s site was comprehensively rejected. There was one vote in favour of acceptance and 10 votes against. One member of the committee had left the meeting.
It was a long morning. We were there at 1000 but didn’t get our chance until 1230. First up was the proposed Cambridge City football ground in Sawston. Officers had recommended rejection because the development would be in the green belt but the committee disagreed and voted for it. Shortly thereafter the committee approved the development brief for the Fulbourn and Ida Darwin Hospitals site in Fulbourn before rejecting, again against officer advice, the outline planning application for the Ida Darwin site.
Then we were on. First Steve Temple spoke on behalf of objectors. Second is usually a speaker from the developer but Mitre declined to participate although it was present in the upstairs gallery. I spoke on behalf of the parish council. Click here to see what I had planned to say. Actually I mistimed it and had to trim the last few paragraphs. Finally Edd Stonham and Neil Davies spoke as ‘local councillors’.
There was then a short debate with interesting comments:
Cllr Kindersley: ‘it seems that this is a development that nobody likes, neither the local community, its councillors nor the parish councillors. It seems that even the developer doesn’t like it because it declined to appear before the Design Review Panel.’
Cllr Clarke: ‘… a tsunami of objection …’
Cllr Hartford: ‘ (another ground for rejection) lack of compliance with the emerging South Cambs Local Plan’.
We were fortunate to be able to refer to such overwhelming local support for rejection and to be able to table two critiques of the design put together for us by local architects Nigel Walter of Archangel (click here) and Jonathan Polley of JPA (click here). I guess this would have been what the plan would have got from the Design Review Panel so it’s not surprising that Mitre declined to appear before it.
It’s not over yet. Mitre has called for an inquiry on the grounds of non-determination and we need to work with South Cambs to ensure that Mitre does not win this round.